Category Archives: singer songwriter

KATE BUSH – Director’s Cut

Posted on by

KBKate Bush is a brilliantly talented, unique individual who has provided inspiration to thousands of musicians and singer-songwriters. She’s recorded a handful of the best tracks of the 1980s, with her 1985 album ‘The Hounds of Love’ being not far short of a masterpiece. However, such talents bring with them an artistic temperament. Her first (and so far only) greatest hits package, 1986’s ‘The Whole Story’ features a re-working of her classic ‘Wuthering Heights’, since Kate was unhappy with the already brilliant original. The ’86 version, featuring a significantly lower and more limited vocal range – isn’t a patch on the original, despite what KB herself thinks. She’s also gone on record stating how much she dislikes her earlier work. Presumably, then, this is why we’ve been denied a fully comprehensive DVD of any kind, even though her promo videos and her only filmed live show from Hammersmith ’79 have been treasured by fans for years on old VHS releases. If we take into account the never-officially released stuff like the mimed performance at the Efterling theme park for Dutch TV or the 45 minute 1979 BBC Christmas special featuring Peter Gabriel – both of which have been widely circulated over the years – that’s a world of stuff which has never seen the light on day on DVD…

After the late 80s, she was rarely seen in public and appearances on television were just as scarce. We can guess that this is because she no longer looked like the 20 year old who pranced around in leotards, an argument given some weight by the ridiculously airbrushed promotional photograph accompanying this ‘Director’s Cut’ release. Has most of Kate Bush’s career hinged on how she feels she is perceived by the public? Possibly. What’s definite though, is that her striving for perfection – to obsessively airbrush the bits of the past which make her unhappy – leaps to new heights on ‘Director’s Cut’. It’s not a best of; nor is it a remix project. ‘Director’s Cut’ features a selection of songs originally released on Kate’s 1991 and 1993 albums ‘The Sensual World’ and ‘The Red Shoes’; and for better or worse, they’re re-imagined here in a way which pleases Kate – though they’re unlikely to be favoured over the original cuts by anyone else.

At first, ‘The Song of Solomon’ doesn’t appear to veer too far from the original version. The bass has a bigger role, bringing a slightly dubby quality and Kate’s vocal doesn’t appear as prominent, and then we get to the end where a previous vocal line is substantially altered. Whereby in the original version ‘Whap bam boom’ appears tagged on the end of a line, almost as an after-breath, here, Kate delivers the line at full pelt and then loops it so it becomes impossible to miss.  It’s a mistake; a very bad idea, which spoils anything which has gone before. Unless you’re Richard Penniman, there’s no excuse for ‘whap bam boom’.

‘Lily’ is a little better. Gone are the late 80s synthetic sounding drums, they’ve been sidelined for something more natural. The production sounds a little compressed, Kate’s voice is a little lower, but the performances themselves are commendable. ‘Never Be Mine’, ‘Top of The City’ and ‘And So Is Love’ each get a dusting down which doesn’t improve the original cuts in any obvious way and as before, Kate’s vocals aren’t as powerful; even so, they’re not objectionable, just a little pointless. Thankfully, Kate has opted to keep Eric Clapton’s guitar leads from the latter intact. Since those guitar lines provided one of the original version’s best features, to replace them with something different would have been madness.

‘Deeper Understanding’, meanwhile, has been completely butchered. What would improve the atmospheric, multilayered original with its fretless bass parts? Nothing. …But clearly, Kate’s opinion differed. She’s wrong. Maybe she should have had someone to tell her that once in a while. The keyboards are the same as before, but the bass is buried in the new inferior mix and what’s more, the track features a truckload of auto-tuned elements. Granted, the song is – at least in part – about computers, but that’s no reason to think your audience would want to hear it sang by an emotionless robot. ‘The Red Shoes’, meanwhile retains a fair amount of its original bounce, but not all of its original spark, due to a smoothing out of the 80s edges and Kate’s re-recorded vocal not quite hitting the marks of the ’91 model.

Alongside these tweaked cuts, ‘Director’s Cut’ features three tracks which have been totally re-recorded. The steamy ‘Sensual World’ (now re-titled ‘Flower of the Mountain’) reinstates words from James Joyce’s ‘Ulysses’ which Kate had been refused permission to use back in 1991. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but everything else about it really awful. The drums have been removed, the bass turned up and the production has a nasty, muddy sound. Kate’s vocal in a lower key really doesn’t match the dreamy performance on original cut of ‘The Sensual World’; in fact, it sounds like a warbling noise from an old lady. This is supposedly one of ‘Director’s Cut’s greatest achievements, but frankly, this has the sound of a middling demo take. If you hadn’t already lamented the fact that Kate’s voice isn’t a patch on its ‘Sensual World’ era equivalent you certainly will here. By the time she reaches the last verse, it feels like she’s barely trying to put in any effort at all. She’s absolutely deluded if she thinks this is an improvement.

The brilliantly played piano part of ‘Moments of Pleasure’ gets a slower arrangement here to the point where it’s almost unrecognisable. Again, this has a lot to do with the lower key. Kate’s vocal is okay but certainly not outstanding. The bouncy pop of ‘Rubberband Girl’ appears as an odd shuffling number combining a Rolling Stones inspired rhythmic twang with brushed drumming. A potentially good idea is made unlistenable by compressed production which makes everything sound underwater, while Kate’s vocal is understated and somewhat mumbly. It’s like listening with your fingers in your ears. A brief bass line which sounds like a stretching rubber band provides a great moment but it’s really fleeting.

We all change. Change is natural. We change as people – our personal views change, our tastes in music change. Slowly over time, everything about us changes. Kate Bush needs to accept that too and not indulge in exercises of warped revisionism. The overtly narcissistic ‘Director’s Cut’ only exists to massage Kate’s ego and to give her many sycophantic fans something to get excited about, since they don’t have anything wholly new. The past is the past, you can’t change it; you certainly shouldn’t attempt to rewrite it. The world doesn’t need the musical equivalent of plastic surgery, especially when such surgery brings little to no improvement.

‘Director’s Cut’ isn’t the work of the once brilliant and unique Kate Bush…it’s a totally misguided affair, presenting the ugliest face of vanity. If Kate wants to piss on her legacy that’s fine – after all, they’re her songs to mistreat as she wishes – but she shouldn’t expect everyone to still love her unconditionally afterwards.

May 2011

ELIZA CARTHY – Angels & Cigarettes

Posted on by

carthyBeing the daughter of English folk legends Martin Carthy and Norma Waterson (and the niece of Lal and Mike Waterson), you could say that music was very much in Eliza Carthy’s blood. It would also seem natural for her career to explore avenues of traditional (and traditional sounding) English folk music. She gained great praise for her double release ‘Red:Rice’ in 1998 – the first part fusing her folk songwriting with modern drum loops and the second being stripped back, venturing down a more traditional folk route.

Her fourth album (and US debut) ‘Angels & Cigarettes’ presents Carthy at her most commercial; the songs are more in the adult singer-songwriter pop mould than usual, although her folk influences are occasionally present.

The opening number ‘Whispers of Summer’ is largely representative of this album’s shift away from folk music. Eliza’s voice is still very much in the heavily accented folk vein and her gently played fiddle may put in an appearance, but this is tempered by an unobtrusive drum loop and backing vocals whose ‘oohs’ aren’t particulary folky. A far cry from the likes of ‘The Snow It Melts The Soonest’ or the jigs and reels present on ‘Rice’, it feels like one of the album’s folkiest numbers, but it’s barely folk. It’s one of the only times Eliza gets anywhere near her trademark fiddle style and then that’s only a flourish rather than its main feature.

‘Perfect’ is lightweight pop which manages to remain charming due to Eliza’s lilting folky vocal; ‘Fuse’ makes excellent use of strings and Eliza’s voice carries much sadness. ‘Breathe’ is fantastic with its use of piano and Massive Attack style drum loop. The real star here is Barnaby Stradling whose bass playing is superb and adds much needed warmth. ‘Train Song’ is dark and brooding, where the vocals are used to create beautiful harmonies over the strings, in turn used sparingly to create atmosphere. Similarly, the bass-led ‘Whole’ works well due to being very musically understated. The end result is brilliant, but (as with a lot of ‘Angels & Cigarettes’) it’s not necessarily what some Eliza Carthy fans are looking for; it could just as easily have been a Beth Orton number. A cover of Paul Weller’s ‘Wildwood’ suits Carthy’s vocal style very well and is further proof that ‘Angels & Cigarettes’ seemed largely pre-occupied with the idea of being a cross-over album, introducing Carthy to an adult pop audience and hopefully breaking the US in the process.

If you’re not much of a fan of English folk in its purest forms but don’t mind a little creeping in, ‘Angels & Cigarettes’ offers your best entry point into Carthy’s work – and especially so, if you have a passing fancy for Kirsty MacColl or Beth Orton, for example. Eliza’s rendition of ‘Wildwood’ is worth your time alone.

February 2010

MARCEL LEGANE – Heart Life EP

Posted on by

leganeMarcel Legane’s second release has a striking clarity; his well-crafted songs are given a great boost by crisp production. The solid drum sound and sharp guitars lend themselves well to his brand of radio-friendly brand of emo influenced pop-rock. We’re not talking instant gratification though; Legane’s song writing style is one where those great moments only really present themselves after two or three listens…but once you’ve familiarised yourself with his sound, it’s obvious he’s a man who knows how to mix occasionally quirky arrangements with memorable hooks.

The opening number ‘Heart Receding’ has a sound which captures the listener’s attention from the start thanks to a great drum sound courtesy of Ollie Waton. There’s great interplay between his spiky drum pattern and Ross Chapman’s ringing guitar chords, which are both under pinned by a semi-busy bass line from Adam Double. Legane’s vocals have elements of softness throughout the verses, but as the choruses kick in, his voice sounds strong. There’s a small amount of auto-tune at play (as a stylistic choice, I think), but the track didn’t really need it – I’m sure Legane’s natural delivery would have shone through. The second number builds on the strengths of the opener; Legane sounds more confident delivering an extremely tuneful vocal line over slightly quirky pop-rock. The musical high points here come courtesy of another busy bass line and new wave inspired keyboards.

‘Superior/Inferior’ is this release’s absolutely essential track. Waton delivers a playful drum part which has a very percussive style. The verses are built around sparse rhythmic qualities, but for the pre-chorus and louder sections, his pounding drum style echoing the lyrics “don’t cast my dream aside/the sound of your judgement pounding out”. Legane’s vocal range isn’t especially broad, but his style is well suited to the musical style. The simplicity of the vocal line is at odds with the relative complexity of the drum part, but the result is one which seems effective. It’s a track which stands up to many repeated listens.

After a strong intro dominated by Waton’s drums, ‘Games’ becomes a little sickly, as Legane launches into a tune which sounds a little too boy-band, but that alone may have been okay (as far as these things go), but the whole of the opening verse is drenched in auto-tune. If you imagine the kind of auto-tune Fall Out Boy’s Patrick Stump has to help him with those long notes, only slapped across absolutely everything and you’ll get the picture. It’s a couple of notches short of the inhuman qualities explored by Cher on ‘Believe’ (and utilised on countless hideous pieces of r ‘n’ b), but it still has an unnecessary inhuman quality. As the music progresses, things don’t seem so bad, particularly on the slightly rockier moments, but even so, the over commercial edges of this number don’t capture Legane at his best. ‘Friendly Fire’ closes the release with something mellow. Legane’s performance is okay (substantially less auto-tune than before) and it’s more of a slow-burner than the first couple of tracks, but Ross Chapman and Ollie Waton shine throughout – particularly Chapman’s crystal clear guiltar lines.

Compared to his previous release (2010’s ‘Battle EP’), Legane has improved greatly as both a song writer and arranger. In becoming far surer of the sound he wants to achieve, on this EP he finds himself in a position to enlist better musicians – and this alone ensures ‘Heart Life’ offers a decent listening experience, even despite those auto-tuned elements.

March 2010

STILL SPARK – Still Spark

Posted on by

Photobucket

Bringing together Boston musician Seth Freeman (previously of Little John) and songwriter/engineer Dan O’Leary, this debut release by Still Spark is a sum of many influences. Across ten cuts, the duo – augmented by several session musicians – deliver moments of power pop, straight up adult rock/pop and occasional rootsy numbers. While it promises a great deal, unfortunately their slightly sporadic mix of styles doesn’t always hit the mark.

‘Love Comes Calling’ is upbeat and summery, with chiming guitars, handclaps and quirky harmony vocals. It makes a decent opening number and lead single with its feel-good nature, but misses out slightly due to a slightly wobbly lead vocal. His untrained vocal style kills most of the spirit during ‘Caroline’, despite the musical having some decent moments (which once again, are delivered to the listener by way of chiming guitars and sunny vibes). ‘The Way I Am’ starts out in a similarly punchy power pop mood, driven by Cars-esque staccato rhythms and big chords, but once you’re convinced we’re headed for an equally big chorus and key change, it softens and wanders into jangle-pop territory, with the electric riff complimented by acoustic guitar work. The chorus itself isn’t far off being a one-liner, sadly, but some good backing harmonies go some way to making it memorable.

The gentle acoustic vibes and the wordiness at the heart of ‘Still On Your Side’ seems far better suited to the slightly drawly vocal. Once the backing vocal harmonies are added alongside a few guitar flourishes, it provides one of the moments where Still Spark shine a little brighter; but as before, when Freeman attempts to hit bigger notes, things fall more than a little flat. The Gin Blossoms styled jangle-pop of ‘Best Times’ features some excellent ringing guitar work and pleasing harmonies, pulled together with a great hook. Topped off with a slightly raucous solo, it’s a track which clearly presents Still Spark in good form.

Over the course of the last few tracks, there’s a definite upturn in the album’s fortunes. The doo-wop meets power pop of ‘Careless Thing’ is, without question, the album’s best number. What could have been a typically flat vocal is given a boost by a female lead courtesy of Gaby Moreno, whose slightly quirky, expressive voice is given a chance to really shine when accompanied by sharp guitar chords and an upfront bass. The chiming guitars opening ‘Good Woman’ at first lead the listener into thinking we’re headed for Teenage Fanclub/Big Star territory, but soon, the grooves recall The Connells in a rather chipper mood. A few layered harmony vocals on the chorus pick things up even further, creating a track that’s nothing short of being a three minute ray of sunshine. It’s a great pity Still Spark couldn’t have tapped into this feel-good style a little more often.

The mid-paced ‘The Limelight’ showcases simple rhythms and a natural sounding vocal, augmented by some clean toned electric guitar fills, presenting Still Spark in a relaxed mood which evokes The Jayhawks. It’s a great way to finish the disc, leaving the listener with a strong memory of Still Spark in good form. The female backing vocals are slightly overdone (maybe even unnecessary), but do nothing to spoil what’s essentially a great roots-rock number.

With this self-titled disc, Still Spark have delivered a release that’s not always rootsy enough to deserve the roots rock tag, and with regards to occasional their power pop tendencies, these are often not quite breezy enough to hit their stride with the devastating effect deserved. However, as evidenced on the last few tracks, it’s not a release without merit. With regards to the lesser moments, even when the material doesn’t always work as well as you’d hope, Kay Hanley’s production brings a great sound. Worth checking out for a couple of tracks, but listening is certainly advised before making a purchase.

March 2011

JOHN WESLEY – The Lilypad Suite

Posted on by

wesley

Beginning his career as guitarist with the largely unknown band Autodrive in the early 90s, John Wesley gained wider recognition when he supported Marillion in 1994 on their ‘Brave Tour’. His debut album, ‘Under The Red and White Sky’, released earlier that year, is a strong work with a superb rock/pop sound, showcasing Wes as an emerging talented song writer. While the songs speak for themselves, it can’t have hurt that the album had a great supporting cast of musicians, including Marillion members Steve Rothery, Mark Kelly and Ian Mosley. A few years later, Wes gained even more recognition when he became touring guitarist for the legendary progressive rock outfit Porcupine Tree.

Over the years, it’s been possible to hear Wes grow as a musician, each of his albums exploring different avenues, but always with strong song writing at the core of his work. His sixth studio release, ‘The Lilypad Suite’, isn’t a concept piece, though each of the songs are inspired by the struggle of a young girl coming to terms with the absence of a father.

‘A.M.W.’ opens things rather bleakly. The guitars make grinding noises like a train pulling into a station and scraping on the rails. Against the grinding and droning noises, Wes adopts a husky tone to his voice and states he’s “going to California” and those left behind “will have to find their place”. This leads swiftly into ‘Walls of America’, opening with a full compliment of reverb, over which Wes lays down a guitar line which has plenty of atmosphere amongst the echoed drones. Mark Prater’s drum sound has a live quality and Wes’s lead vocal has an edge which is suited to the slightly alternative hard rock. The track is lent an element of softness by some rather pleasing harmonies on the chorus vocal, but overall, it sounds like a work half a lifetime away from the young singer-songwriter who shared a stage with Marillion in the 90s. The semi-acoustic poppy vibes at the heart of ‘A Glittery Nothing’ leave no doubt that this is the very same musician though; Wes’s softer vocal stylings are joined by clean toned guitar work and a sunnier, more optimistic vibe. The guitar solo reverts back to a distorted sound -almost drowned out by a sheet of reverb – but once that’s over, it’s a quick return to the beautifully played acoustic edged rock/pop. Those whom found a great deal of enjoyment from Wes’ ‘Under The Red and White Sky’ debut will undoubtedly find this number one of ‘The Lilypad Suite’s stand out cuts.

While most of ‘Still Waiting’ centres around elements which are in abundance elsewhere (chiefly the dominant guitars and dark atmospheres), the opening riff is brilliantly heavy – sounding not unlike something which might at the core of the heavy parts of post-‘In Absentia’ Porcupine Tree. The best moments come near the song’s end, though, when multi-tracked guitars offer not only the heavy opening riff, but also some reverbed atmospheres overlaid by a cleaner lead. With three distinctly separate guitar lines, both Wes and Dean Tidey deliver an interesting arrangement, without resorting to overt showmanship. The ringing guitars and hushed vocals which drive ‘Lost’ have a haunting quality; the chorus refrain has an element of simplicity, but Wes’s emotive voice brings out the absolute best in the arrangement, while his slightly distorted guitar work brings with it another great atmosphere. The softness of the opening of ‘Firelight’ is reminiscent of Wes’s early work, but this soon gives way to yet another wall of heavily reverbed guitars, over which, Wes’s vocal builds gradually. Mark Prater’s simple, pounding drum riffs carry weight and appear sympathetic towards a number which could have ended up sounding somewhat leaden. The close of the number features some rather furious playing over an already powerful arrangement.

Although only comprising five new songs and an intro, ‘The Lilypad Suite’ is an accomplished work and well worth investigating. While fans will undoubtedly continue to sing John Wesley’s praises, first time listeners may want to check out a couple of his earlier works first, with both ‘Under The Red and White Sky’ (1994) and ‘Chasing Monsters’ (2002) being strongly recommended.

Buy CDs from Wes here.

March 2011